Let’s say one of my jail patients has a moderate-sized inguinal hernia. I want to schedule surgery to have the hernia fixed, but to do so, I have to get authorization. This is not unusual. Just like the outside, before I can do medical procedures or order non-formulary drugs, I must get the approval of the entity that will pay the bill. By contract, my jails house inmates from a variety of jurisdictions, such as the Federal Marshals, ICE, the State Department of Corrections and other counties. This process of “Utilization Management” is very similar to getting pre-authorization from an insurance company or Medicaid in the free world, probably because Corrections simply copied the outside pre-authorization process.
Having done this process hundreds of times over the years, both in the free world and in Correctional Medicine, I am struck by a phrase that keeps coming up: “medically necessary.” When authorization for a procedure is denied, the reason often given is that it is “not medically necessary.” I then have to argue that what I am requesting is, indeed, medically necessary. The problem is that there are many possible definitions of “medically necessary,” and I believe many disagreements arise because two parties understand “medical necessity” differently.
For those interested in the Bath Salts phenomenon that I wrote about in “Bath Salts,” A Review and Bath Salts Update, CNBC is airing an hour-long program tonight about the “Bath Salts” and “Incense” phenomenon entitled Crime Inc.: A Deadly High. The program promises to explore in detail this marketing phenomenon, as well as the designer drug analogue issue, in which chemists make minor changes to the chemical structure of an illicit chemical, thus making it legal. Who knew that bath salts and incense generate an estimated $5 billion per year!
Crime Inc.: A Deadly High airs tonight, August 2nd, at 8:00, 9:00 and midnight on CNBC.
This U.S. Preventative Services Task Force guideline replaces the one issued in 2003 and contains several important changes that will impact correctional facilities.
1. Less than age 21. No PAP smears before age 21. No HPV (Human Papilloma Virus) screening. Period.
2. Age 21-30. PAP smears every 3 years. No HPV testing.
3. Age 30-65. PAP smears every 5 years. HPV testing begins and is also done every five years.
4. Age older than 65. No PAP smears.
Implementing these official government guidelines will result in big changes in my facilities. One of the facilities that I am the Medical Director for is the Idaho Juvenile Correctional Facility, which we call JCC and is the state juvenile prison. Heretofore, we have done HPV testing and PAP smears on all of the girls entering the JCC. According to these new guidelines, we should stop. I need to discuss the matter with the medical administrator there (I’ll be calling, Mardi)!
The adult women in the state prison have been getting PAP smears as often as yearly and have come to expect them. According to the new guidelines, we would only do them every 3 years from ages 21-30 and every five years thereafter until age 65.
On a personal note, a relative of mine (who prefers to not be identified) continues to dutifully report to her gynecologist for her annual “exam,” (including a PAP smear) even though she is well into her 80s.
The U.S. Preventative Services Task Force did not comment on the potential economic impact of this guideline, but it seems that it has the potential to save a lot of money in correctional facilities. How much did your institution spend on PAP smears and HPV testing last year? If you adopt these new guidelines, cut that in half. At least.
Have you already implemented these guidelines at your facility? How has it worked out?
Have you considered these new guidelines but have not implemented them? Why not?
Essentials of Correctional Medicine is approved for CME credit!
Essentials of Correctional Medicine has been approved for 19.5 hours of Continuing Medical Education Credit by the American Academy of Family Physicians. This conference should be a great learning experience as well as a good way to get Correctional Medicine specific CMEs!